News
July 18, 2008
Mountaintop removal as tourism?

KAYFORD, W.Va. -- From his 50-acre peninsula of forest surrounded by a sea of mountaintop removal activity, Larry Gibson hosts a sort of Exhibition Coal Mine in reverse.

"There's a 900-acre mountaintop removal mine right next to my land and a total of 13 permitted mines around me," he said. "I'm completely surrounded by it."

When Gibson was a child, his patch of woodland on Kayford Mountain used to lie below a series of higher knobs and ridges extending into Raleigh County. Now his place is the highest point on the mountain.

1 of 2 Photos
Lawrence Pierce
All phases of the mountaintop removal mining process can be seen from Gibson’s tract of land.
For better or worse - and Gibson will be quick to tell you it's for the worse - his place now offers one of the best viewpoints this side of an airplane cabin to get a look at mountaintop mining in action.

Since the late 1980s, when MTR began to change the landscape around his home, thousands of people have visited his property to see for themselves what the process involves.

"I've had people from Israel, Australia - from all over the world - come here," said Gibson, as he sat on the porch of his solar-powered cabin. In the past 18 months, more than 1,300 people have signed his guest book after making the drive to the head of Cabin Creek Road, then up a winding gravel road to the Stanley Heirs Park, the land trust Gibson created to protect his land in perpetuity.

Among them were CNN's Anderson Cooper, who later named Gibson a "CNN Hero" for his work in defending the planet; Robert F. Kennedy Jr., here to film a documentary based on his book "Crimes Against Nature," and singer, songwriter and Cross Lanes native Kathy Mattea.

"In the last 20 years, we've had over 12,000 people come here," said Gibson. "We get schoolchildren, college students, church groups, environmental groups and people who just want to see what mountaintop removal is all about. And George Bush has sent more reporters to me than anyone else."

Starting on Saturday, the West Virginia Sierra Club will begin hosting once-monthly minivan tours to Gibson's property from Morgantown and Charleston. Other dates for the tours include Aug. 16 and Sept. 13.

"Even here in coal country, a lot of people still don't know what MTR is and does," said Jim Sconyers, conservation chair of the state Sierra Club.

"If you're not an avid conservationist, chances are good you've barely heard of it. But once you've seen it, the scales will fall from your eyes. And since everyone who turns on a light switch is in a sense responsible for it, everyone needs to know what MTR involves."

"I do this to educate people," Gibson said. "MTR is still one of West Virginia's best-kept secrets. While some people outside the coalfields are beginning to hear about it, they don't really understand the effects of what it does until they see for themselves. Here, you can do that."

Gibson left Kanawha County for Ohio when the deep mine where his father worked closed. He worked in a Cleveland-area auto manufacturing plant until the mid-1980s, when he returned to Kayford Mountain, and bought what was left of the family homeplace.

"They started surface mining here in '86 or '87," he recalled. "The first dynamite I heard going off was in 1987, from off in the distance. Now, it goes off as much as 12 times a day from just below here."

Gibson said he has grown so accustomed to the constant growl and clatter of heavy equipment in operation just off his property boundaries that he barely notices it. Blasting is another matter. In addition to noise and tremors, and a series of deep, foot-wide cracks jutting across his land, rocks from blasting at the mine routinely fall on his lawn and family cemetery.

Advertiser
Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close

0 / 150
Posted By: LindyB (5:23pm 07-21-2008)
Report Abuse


That would be what's to be done with water contaminated with mercury, arsenic and selenium. I can spell, I just can't type.

Posted By: LindyB (11:59am 07-21-2008)
Report Abuse


Thank you, Rick Steelhammer for doing this piece. I am convinced that once enough people realize what is going on, we will put a stop to this madness. We have a responsibility to the generations that follow us, and I don't think they're going to thank us for poisoned water and polluted air. Renewable energy is the future of WV, and the people who live around MTR sites know this. Reclamation has not worked here, and even if it did, what's to be done water contaminted with mercury, arsenic and selenium? It does not support human life.

Posted By: Darwin (10:57am 07-19-2008)
Report Abuse


Chris, neither of those site have ANYTHING to do with WV mountain top removal.

Sage Grouse??? Do you have any idea where sage grouse live? Only 3000 out of 10,000 acres have been reclaimed at the mine. Or did you just look for pretty pictures. And they brag about 14% slopes???

They are quoted as saying "The Trapper Mine employs a meticulous process of saving excavated rock and top soil, using it to refill valleys and pits left by coal mining, and then seeding the reclaimed swaths with a variety of plants and grasses." Show us where a WV mine "meticulously" does the same thing.

Associated Electric sites are in the midwest where they also save the topsoil. How much topsoil do they save at MTR site? What is thickness of topsoil in the midwest compared to what is found in Southern West Virginia.

Also lets compare AOC at those site and AOC in WV. Think are comparable?

The photos are propaganda, pure and simple. They have no connection with our reality.

Posted By: Chris (8:57am 07-19-2008)
Report Abuse


I posted some of this yeserday but it wasn't printed here. Here are a few pictures of reclaimed land. What was once just unusable hills are now beautiful plains with trees and accessiblity. I suggest some of you quit looking at mines in production and look at the land a few years after a mine has reclaimed the land.

http://www.imcc.isa.us/Photos/images/AssocElecSite1.jpg
http://www.blm.gov/nhp/spotlight/sage_grouse/images/Trapper-Reclaim.jpg

It's easy to follow the top stories with home delivery of The Charleston Gazette.

Click here to order home delivery.

Advertiser
Advertiser