August 19, 2008
Dueling PR campaigns compete for coal's fate
One backs industry, other likes wind power
Advertiser

CHARLESTON, W.Va. - This morning, West Virginia political leaders and industry officials will gather at a Charleston hotel to promote coal's role in meeting the nation's energy needs.

At the same time, in cyberspace, the group Coal River Mountain Watch plans to launch a national campaign to build a wind energy project - instead of permitting a series of strip mines - in Raleigh County.

Gov. Joe Manchin, Sen. Jay Rockefeller and Rep. Shelley Moore Capito will be among the speakers at the Coal Forum event at the Embassy Suites hotel.

Participants will focus on recommendations from the business group Imagine West Virginia: more money for coal-related research, promoting safer mining practices, training more miners, and better promoting the industry.

Among the top goals is "a re-branding of the state's image across the nation and around the globe as one that is most progressive, forward-thinking and responsible when managing energy and environmental challenges in tandem."

The Coal River Wind Project's online campaign is run by grass-roots activists, using high-tech wind studies and mapping software to package what they say is a real alternative to continued reliance on mountaintop removal mining.

"This would be the biggest wind farm proposed on the East Coast, and could provide a model for other countries in West Virginia looking to develop affordable, clean energy and create safe, healthy jobs in their own communities," said Matt Noerpel, a spokesman for Whitesville-based Coal River Mountain Watch.

The climate change crisis, skyrocketing energy prices, two years of repeated mine safety disasters and the continued battle over mountaintop removal have the coal industry in the headlines.

At the same time, dueling campaigns like the Coal Forum and the Coal River Wind Project offer competing views not just of the answers to the nation's energy problems, but conflicting ideas of what the questions themselves should be.

Industry supporters say coal must continue to play a major role in the national and world energy mix. Environmental groups say mining is already doing too much damage, and that coal's greenhouse emissions make it a major threat to the planet's climate system.

For example, Coal River Mountain Watch calls its wind proposal "an exciting new energy option."

Organizers are promoting construction of 220 2-megawatt wind turbines on Coal River Mountain ridges. A wind study, funded by North Carolina-based Appalachian Voices, concluded the spot is a good location for a wind farm. The project, the group says, would create enough wind power to "keep the lights on" in 150,000 homes "while preserving the mountain for future economic and community benefits."

Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: Steve from Sissonville (4:37am 08-21-2008)
Report Abuse


If they would coke the coal, thereby extracting it's hydrogen rich liquids and gases, blend the coke with, flyash and cement and put that mixture back into underground mines, it would be possible to completely remove all of the coal from a seam in a manner that would be cost effective and not deteriorate the surface above the mine. I agree that the wanton permitting of mountaintop removal mines, when there is no legitimate post use plan is (or should be) criminal. Only partial permits should be allowed in areas where roadways will be built or where community development is needed and non-flood plain land is scarce.
The coal industry has been it's own worst enemy by fighting every regulation governing it.
It is possible to mine and use coal and it's byproducts, safely, economically and in an environmentally friendly way but the industry will have to be forced to do this against their will because they have consistently chosen short term profit over their own long term viability.

Posted By: wvroads (10:47am 08-20-2008)
Report Abuse


We know the fate of coal. It will eventually be gone. We also know the fate of WV if they don't stop MTR. It will eventally be gone along with the mountains, the people, the air, the water, and everything else that we in WV care about. Be a slave to coal and we will all pay the price. Stop MTR now and make them mine underground until it's all gone. At least we keep the land and people after coal is gone.

Posted By: DavisJms7 (7:51am 08-20-2008)
Report Abuse


To all the people who post comments about articles such as this one on the continued destruction of our state...have you noticed that Governor Manchin and his cronies has paid no attention to anything you have said? It makes you feel good to be ignored, does it not? This November, vote JAMES DAVIS for Governor and he will listen to your voice and give it a place back in your government. If you put Joe Manchin or his mirror reflection Russ Weeks back in office, in four years Joe Manchin can have this state completely destroyed and handed over to big destructive businesses. Make a change and vote JAMES DAVIS in November.

Posted By: MoreSense (10:55pm 08-19-2008)
Report Abuse


Mountaintop mines reduce the altitude of the ridges by hundreds of feet, which reduces the wind speed (why do you think they build wind turbines to be so tall???), and thus eliminates alot of the energy production that could have occurred had the wind farm been built on the ridges of an intact mountain. Not only that, as a study related to the one that was used for the Coal River Wind Campaign showed, the loss of hundreds of feet of altitude actually reduces the wind speed so much, that the winds were not powerful enough for large wind developers to be able to place turbines there, because with the lower energy production, the development of a utility scale wind farm was no longer economically viable. So I have a better suggestion, "Sensible," how about we preserve the ridges where you can produce massive amounts of clean, renewable energy, FOREVER, instead of eliminating those vast wind resources through mountaintop removal. How about wind on Coal River Mountain? Sounds sensible to me

Advertisement - Your ad here
Advertisement - Your ad here
MC CORMICK JEWELERS
A name you have know and trusted for over 60 years for honesty, quality and fair prices. The own...
Advertisement - Your ad here