September 27, 2009
Emily, John Perdue discuss MU grades controversy
Advertiser

CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- Emily Perdue said she did nothing wrong and got no special treatment when she earned two A grades this summer to replace two "incomplete" grades for courses she took during the spring 2009 semester at Marshall University.

During an interview on Sunday, Perdue said she received the incomplete grades after she withdrew from two courses taught by Laura Wyant, a professor of adult and technical education at Marshall.

"I did nothing wrong. I was not given grades for classes I didn't take," Perdue said. "I did not ask for special treatment and I did not get special treatment."

A controversy erupted last week after two previously confidential internal memos were released by an unknown source.

"My privacy as a student was violated by that action," Perdue said.

At the end of her freshman year, Perdue decided to major in business education. She recently changed her major to business management.

"Last year, I had 15 hours of independent study during one semester. I wasn't happy and wanted to get out of the program. That is one reason I changed majors," Perdue said on Sunday.

Perdue explained that she arranged with Wyant to withdraw from the two classes under an agreement where Rosalyn Templeton, executive dean of Marshall's College of Education and Human Services, would give her grades to replace the incompletes.

After the summer semester, Templeton gave Perdue A's in both courses after Perdue completed the course requirements. Wyant insists she should have played a role in awarding those grades.

"It was agreed upon between the dean and the professor," Perdue said. "I met with Templeton from mid-May to August 14 to go over my assignments.

"I take my education very seriously and I have earned a 3.4 grade point average at Marshall."

On Sunday, Perdue thumbed through copies of 15 different assignments she completed for each of the two courses.

Those courses -- "Administrative Office Management" and "Marketing and Sales Promotion" -- required Perdue to create 15 lesson plans for potential students in each of those two subject areas.

In each of the 30 detailed lesson plans, Perdue listed objectives, immediate goals, long-range goals, procedures and materials needed to reach those goals.

The current controversy erupted after September 11, when Wyant sent an internal memo to Marshall Registrar Roberta Ferguson.

"I issued a grade of 'I' in each course ... at the conclusion of the spring semester. I had not seen any work completed by Ms. Perdue for either course. Therefore I cannot change the grade," Wyant's memo stated.

Wyant stated she understood "Templeton would be listed as a co-instructor in those courses."

Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: HighlandBoy (3:41pm 09-29-2009)
Report Abuse


Jadel,

Your posts seem to have information not contained in any story I can find on the internet. If you are holding relevant information in this matter you should share it with Paul Nyden. Do you work at Marshall? You seem better informed that the rest of us. You seem also to have made up your mind that there is only one possible explaination. Professor Wyant's. The rest of us are waiting on the truth to come out. It almost always is somewhere in between.

Posted By: jadel (2:23pm 09-29-2009)
Report Abuse


Professor Wyant, was not the one who gave her the "I." That was done by Dean Templeton without consulting professor Wyant. Templeton's role in all this was extremely unusual, to say the least.

Other students said they had little difficulty contacting Professor Wyant during the semester. Did Ms Perdue make any serious effort?

There is no proof that Wyant 'leaked' anything.

Why Ms Perdue was allowed to get an 'I' instead of failing the course is a very good question that Dean Templeton ought to explain. Ms Perdue apparently turned in no work for the class until the semester was over.
That would not qualify her for an 'I' anywhere except,it seems,at Marshall.

True, Provost Ormiston's claim about a 'clerical error' was simply laughable.

If anyone needs to be investigated for unethical conduct, it is Dean Templeton.

Advertisement - Your ad here
Advertisement - Your ad here
ROUTE 21 DINER
Route 21 Diner (formerly Shotguns) is a family owned and run country restaurant. We're open for ...
Deal of the Day - ROUTE 21 DINER
10% off delivery orders
Advertisement - Your ad here