WVGAZETTE.COM/POLITICS
print | email | size
April 22, 2008
Analysis: Pennsylvania is must-win for Clinton

WASHINGTON — Pennsylvania was a must-win state for Hillary Rodham Clinton, the former Democratic presidential front-runner now looking to survive.

Should she lose, it would be a fatal blow to her candidacy -- a defeat so unexpected that it would sap her arguments to remain in the race. It would be the dawn of a Democratic era minus the Clintons as the dominant force.

Clinton has been in must-win territory already this year -- in New Hampshire and then Ohio -- and both times she survived.

Another big victory could give her new energy in the face of calls for her to drop from the race in order to clear front-runner Barack Obama's path to the nomination. It would enable her to argue she's had victories in most of the country's largest states, give her a chance at overtaking Obama's lead in the popular vote and boost her prospects heading into the final stretch of the campaign.

There are seven states left to vote, and the candidates appear likely to split the spoils. Clinton is favored in West Virginia and Kentucky, while Obama is expected to take North Carolina, Oregon and South Dakota. Two states -- Indiana and Montana -- are competitive.

But Clinton has a tough reality to overcome to be nominated no matter what happens -- Obama is practically assured to end the race with a lead in pledged delegates. Even in Pennsylvania, a Clinton victory was never bound to net her much in the delegate count since urban districts where Obama is strong are rewarded more delegates than rural areas where Clinton is likely to do well.

So winning the nomination will require Clinton to get unpledged superdelegates to look past the lead held by the candidate with a shot at becoming the first black president. Many of those superdelegates are elected officials who have constituents to answer to.

No matter what happens in the rest of the race, the odds are stacked high against her winning the nomination. But Clinton has proven that she won't back down when she still has a shot, and a Pennsylvania win would give that to her.

Bill Clinton has already begun making a new argument for her candidacy -- it's the Democratic Party rules that have kept her from becoming the nominee, he told a reporter on the eve of the vote.

The party rules split delegate support instead of allowing the winner of each state to take all the vote, as they do in the general election and in several states on the Republican side.

"We don't have a nominee here because the Democrats chose a system that prevents that result," the former president told The Washington Post.

Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
Advertiser

It's easy to follow the top stories with home delivery of The Charleston Gazette.

Click here to order home delivery.

Advertiser
More Election Central
Election results from selected counties around W.Va.
Kanawha and Putnam county election results 2012 primary
Federal and statewide election results 2012 primary
Other counties primary election results
Despite wins, all not rosy for W.Va. Dems
West Virginia's Democratic Party was largely successful on Election Day, but the results also show a gray lining.
'Real hectic' voting seen in Kanawha
CHARLESTON, W.Va. - Jammed ballot boxes, a power outage and confusion over polling places were among early Election Day problems reported in Kanawha County, County Clerk Vera McCormick said this afternoon.
GOP raises charges of voter fraud
Accusations of voter fraud have hurled a giant mud ball into an already messy presidential campaign, with Republicans alleging that Democrat Barack Obama has close ties to an activist group accused of compiling fake registration forms, including ones for the starting lineup of the Dallas Cowboys - submitted in Nevada.
McCain makes brief stop in state
KENOVA - John McCain's stop in West Virginia was brief Wednesday. He got off his campaign plane and onto another version of the "Straight Talk Express," his campaign bus.
Servicemen see presidential campaign through unique lens
WASHINGTON - Brandon Ziegler served two tours in Iraq and wears a bracelet inscribed with the name of an Army buddy who never made it home. Jim Morin saw action in both Iraq and Afghanistan and has lost several friends to the war in Iraq, the latest just a month ago.
Obama plan would expand Bush's faith-based program
CHICAGO -- Reaching out to evangelical voters, Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama is announcing plans to expand President Bush's program steering federal social service dollars to religious groups and - in a move sure to cause controversy - support some ability to hire and fire based on faith.
Obama can win West Virginia, Manchin says
After meeting with other "centrist" leaders of the Democratic Party for two days in Chicago, Gov. Joe Manchin said Monday he believes Illinois Sen. Barack Obama can carry West Virginia in November.
Ad targets McCain on Iraq war
WASHINGTON - A major labor union and the liberal organization MoveOn.org are joining forces to air a provocative new ad portraying John McCain's Iraq policy as a prolonged presence that would involve a new generation of Americans.
McCain challenges Obama's windfall profits tax
SAN ANTONIO - Republican Sen. John McCain criticized Sen. Barack Obama's call for a windfall profits tax on the oil industry on Tuesday, despite leaving the door open to the same idea last month.
Democrats gather for W.Va. state convention
Hillary Clinton may be out of the presidential race, but West Virginia's Democrats will be adding some names to her roster of national convention delegates this weekend.
Tennant outraised foes before Democratic primary win
A last-minute fundraising surge helped Natalie Tennant get her message out before her May primary win in the Democratic secretary of state's race.