CANDIDATES DIFFER ON SCHOOL CONSOLIDATION
This is the latest in an occasional series focusing on the issues,
records and platforms of the state's candidates for governor.
Today's installment focuses on education.
There he was, the governor of West Virginia, standing behind the
lectern inside the Harts High School gymnasium, doling out grant
money for a new kitchen in the senior center, and he got to talking about
that one-room schoolhouse in Tyler County.
Underwood always talks about the one-room schoolhouse. He has a model
of the schoolhouse in the governor's reception room at the state Capitol.
The one-room schoolhouse he attended as a boy. The one-room schoolhouse
where he worked as a janitor for three years.
And then - and this is where everyone in the packed Lincoln County
gymnasium started to listen - he started talking about technology, wiring
this? - about keeping Lincoln County's four high schools open, about
This from the Republican governor who never spoke against a single
"We need to look at putting together a network to provide services and
eliminate the need for consolidation," Underwood said.
And like that, the people were on their feet. They were electrified.
They were applauding, hooting and hollering. Before Underwood, every state
and local education official had vowed to shut down the four high schools
and build a new one.
But the governor, he was on a roll now, he sensed it, and he was
talking about using the Lincoln distance-learning project as a model for
the rest of the state. The rest of the state.
Underwood had just put the state's most contentious, most divisive
education issue - consolidation - back on the campaign table.
"This is absolutely amazing," said Beth Spence, co-director of
Challenge West Virginia, an organization that
ramifications could be unbelievable. It could change education policy. It
could stop the freight train of closing down schools."
- - -
Congressman Bob Wise's camp was quick to respond to Underwood's
proposal. They dismissed it as an 11th-hour campaign ploy, a cruel
election ploy at that, one that would raise false hopes for Lincoln County
parents and children. Everyone knows the schools are going to close.
"After you do distance learning you're still going to have four
crumbling structures," said Wise, the Democratic challenger. "He walked in
and simply blew up that plan. It shows he's ignorant of the issue or just
used bad judgment."
Underwood hadn't talked about his proposal with state schools
Superintendent David Stewart and Lincoln County Superintendent Bill
Before they debated consolidation, Wise and Underwood discussed
"need-based" college scholarships, raising teacher salaries, raising
up in schools and supports voluntary school prayer. Wise does not.
Neither candidate has come forward with an education plan, platform or
But consolidation, closing schools, will tug, wake and stir the
West Virginia electorate.
The state's education establishment has dug its heels into the notion
that "bigger is better." With a bigger school, you can offer more
advanced courses, more technology, more foreign languages, more counselors
West Virginia's student population is shrinking - and fast. Young
families are leaving the state in droves. Enrollment has declined faster
than any state in the nation. Fewer students, fewer schools needed. End of
But not everyone buys it. Research shows that disadvantaged kids do
better in small schools. The bus rides are shorter. More students
participate in extracurricular activities. The schools help to keep
Before Underwood walked into that Harts High School gymnasium,
it seemed Wise had the small school supporters on his side.
It was something he said last year, something deep and personal that
caught everyone's attention. Wise said he sometimes felt lost in high
The comments came a few months after the Columbine tragedy when some
elected officials, such as North Carolina Gov. Jim Hunt, started talking
about small schools as a way to curb violence.
Wise stated he didn't think a high school should house more than
1,000 students, a middle school no more than 800, an elementary
You won't hear West Virginia education officials rattle off those
limits - though for the most part West Virginia schools are small by
But Wise had given the anti-consolidation folks a glimmer of
"Bob is in no rush to consolidate schools," said Mike Plante, a Wise
- - -
Bob Wise huddled with 70 Riverside High School students in the
AT&T. The company had invited him to chat with students about
Wise asked for a show of hands: How many planned to leave West
The hands sprang up; he was surrounded by hands, a sea of hands.
Everyone, it appeared, had raised a hand.
This frustrates Wise. He says this is what the campaign is about:
keeping West Virginia kids at home.
Wise left the state himself after graduating from George Washington
High School in Charleston. He lived in New Orleans and North
Carolina. He returned to West Virginia 10 years later.
"West Virginia is changing," Wise said. "We need you on the ground
floor to make that change."
And then he made a pitch. "In West Virginia a person can move farther
and faster," he said. "I've never seen a place where a person can move
ahead as fast."
Wise fielded questions from the students. Most wanted to know his
position on student dress codes. (He supports them. Students oppose them.)
Joey Connard, Riverside's student council president, asked about Wise's
position on school size.
Riverside has 1,300 students. Some feel that's too many. Not Connard.
He wanted the congressman's opinion.
"How do you feel about big schools?" Connard asked. "Are you in favor
of a big school like Riverside?"
"I happen to believe education needs to be small," Wise responded. "But
that doesn't mean it cannot happen in a large school. You have to
make sure students don't feel isolated."
Another student jumped up and said many Riverside students feel left
out because they don't participate in extracurricular activities.
"There is a need for all of us to be engaged with one another," Wise
- - -
Mountain Party gubernatorial candidate Denise Giardina and Libertarian
Bob Myers also want to stop the outflow of students from West Virginia.
And they believe education can play a role.
First Giardina: Giardina was talking about consolidation months
before Underwood showed up in the Harts High gymnasium.
Giardina supports small schools - no more than 350 students in an
She thinks schoolchildren spend too much time on buses, not enough in
band and chorus.
She calls the state School Building Authority, which allocates
money for school construction, the "School Bullying
Authority." She says the authority forces consolidation on
communities, using policies that favor "massive educational factories."
She worries about the dozens of elementary schools across the state
that may close in the next 10 years.
"You take the heart and soul out of the community and you waste
resources," said Giardina, a novelist.
Giardina also supports a curriculum rooted in community.
Educators call it "place-based learning" or "experiential learning." A
social studies class interviews seniors about a town's hi
class tests the water in a local stream. An economics class organizes a
meeting of local business leaders.
"If you want to learn about plants," Giardina said, "you go out in the
community and explore plants."
Bob Myers, former president of the state Board of Education, also
"Consolidation is more of a public works project than an
education project," Myers said.
Myers wants to abolish the state Department of Education and
School Building Authority.
He wants to "shatter the education monopoly" (West Virginia has one of
the most centralized education systems in the nation) and establish
independent school districts across the state.
In Lincoln County, for instance, he'd encourage Harts High
School residents to set up their own school board, which, he
asserts, the state constitution allows.
"There are only two elements in our society we institutionalize," Myers
- - -
Bob Wise had just finished his clogging routine for Riverside students
- "Anyone have a zither or banjo?" and Connard and Arpan Kohli talked
about their efforts to unite their classmates. Many attended the former
East Bank and DuPont high schools.
They rattled off all the activities at the school - civil rights
club, Spanish club, foreign language club, and the "best football team in
the state." Connard plays wide receiver.
"But some people you can't help," Kohli said. "They just don't want to
"We've got a great group," Connard said. "Everybody still loves
And then they watched Wise, the AT&T folks and the television
reporters squeeze out the library doors into a mist of cold rain.
"You know, Governor Underwood came here last year," Kohli said. "He
gave us some money, too."
To contact staff writer Eric Eyre, use e-mail or call 348-5194.