June 24, 2009
Insurers purposely cloud data, Rockefeller says
Customers end up knowing less, paying more, senator reports
Advertiser

CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- U.S. Sen Jay Rockefeller accused health insurance companies on Wednesday of routinely keeping customers in the dark about payments for their health care.

Rockefeller, who chairs the Senate Commerce Committee, believes insurance companies intentionally confuse consumers and use false statistics in calculating bills for health services outside their own networks.

"Today's hearing is about protecting consumers," Rockefeller said during his opening statement.

"Consumers can't make real choices because the insurance industry doesn't use standard language or definitions," he said. "And consumers can't challenge insurance companies' decisions because the companies don't explain the terms of coverage in clear, understandable language."

After listening to witnesses testify, Rockefeller asked, "Why is it so hard for consumers to get reliable information?

"When I get a prescription, I get documents with tiny type that you can't read them without a magnifying glass. There is a reason for that, making it so I won't read it."

One witness was Wendell Potter, a former CIGNA vice president and now a senior health care fellow at the Center on Media and Democracy in Madison, Wis.

"Most people are baffled by EOBs" -- the "explanation of benefits" clauses contained in insurance policies -- and "more than half the people in the country do not know what co-payments or co-insurance or prevailing allowances are," Potter said.

He said many people simply give up even trying to understand language in their health-insurance policies.

"Statements from the insurance industry have become far more complex," Potter said.

On Wednesday morning, Rockefeller released a new report by the Senate Office of Oversight and Investigations called "Underpayments to Consumers by the Health Insurance Industry."

"The largest health insurance companies in the United States have been under-reimbursing their customers for out-of-network health-care services," the report stated. "Americans consumers have paid billions of dollars for health care services that their insurance companies should have paid."

Reach Paul J. Nyden at pjny...@wvgazette.com or 304-348-5164.

Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: wvnut123 (8:34am 06-25-2009)
Report Abuse


Since The Senator wants to take credit for creating the Resource Based Relative Value system of reimbursement, maybe he should take some responsibility for the result of that mess which is EOB's he can't read.

Posted By: sadsam (4:53am 06-25-2009)
Report Abuse


Jay may have a big problem reading and understanding an EOB and I don't doubt he does. But I don't and the folks I talk to don't have any problems with them.

Posted By: Caponer (4:42am 06-25-2009)
Report Abuse


Insurance contract language has always been confusing, even for those who are accustomed to using it. Plain-talk has never been a feature of contracts, and it is somewhat wishful thinking to try to change it So, the response to a bad contract is legislation that states what the coverage provisions of insurance shall be. Not what it should be, but what it is. Let the insurers work around that in making their quotes of the premiums they will charge. This way the consumer has only to be concerned with the cost and not the text of the coverage.

Posted By: smarbap (10:13pm 06-24-2009)
Report Abuse


And, of course, we all know that Sen. Rockefeller has absolutely no idea how to "cloud data" to suit his needs.

Advertisement - Your ad here
Advertisement - Your ad here
Advertisement - Your ad here