Op-Ed Commentaries
October 11, 2008
Don Surber: The hillbilly stereotype strikes again
2008 campaign, and new movie, peddle bigotry

THE movie, "The Express," has WVU fans all riled up. It tells the sad story of Ernie Davis, the first black Heisman winner, who died of leukemia before he could make it to the NFL.

Great story - "Brian's Song" for the 21st century.

Unfortunately, that is not the story that filmmakers apparently wanted to sell.

WVU fans are upset with a scene that depicts Davis fighting racism at a game in Morgantown in 1959.

It never happened.

There was no game in Morgantown between his team, Syracuse, and WVU that year. They played in New York. The next year, they played in Morgantown.

And from all accounts, WVU fans treated Davis in the 1960 game as well as they would treat any other star of an opposing team.

Syracuse's 1960 quarterback, Dick Easterly, told the Daily Mail, "I apologize to the people of West Virginia, because it never happened."

But hey, we're West Virginians. We all have "Kick me" signs on our backs.

Of course, what does one expect from Hollywood? The local newspaper, the Los Angeles Times, perpetuates this stereotype of the backward, uneducated, xenophobic bigot who lives in the hills with his wife and his shotgun.

The Times sent a reporter to Whiteville, Va., to find some racists, and he did. There are racists everywhere, of course, but racism in the hills is easier to report because it is so far from the newspaper's circulation area. Readers like to feel morally superior.

The report asserted that because Virginia is leaning Democratic in the Senate race, it should vote for Barack Obama.

Unmentioned in the story was that 68 percent of the people in Whiteville's county voted for President Bush in the last election.

West Virginia elected Democrats as governor in 2000 and 2004, but went for Bush both times. And the state went for Bill Clinton in 1996 but elected a Republican governor.

Perhaps this blue-state, red-state thing is a media myth.

If the L.A. Times is so concerned about racism, it should send a reporter to ask people in South Central L.A. why they won't vote for McCain.

I never agreed with Daily Mail columnist Dave Peyton's assertion that hillbillies were the last ethnic group it was OK to berate.

Advertiser
Report a violation or offensive comment.
[X] Close
to report abuse.
Posted By: One Citizen (7:50am 10-14-2008)
Report Abuse


Why doesn't Don Surber just accuse Senator Obama of writing the screenplay for "The Express" and be done with it?

Surber's bent over backwards to accuse Obama of thinking that we're racist hillbillies. But the Senator's comment about a certain strata of folks being bitter is regularly taken out of context in an obvious attempt to brand Obama as an elitist. But read as a whole, his statement actually warns AGAINST anyone categorizing folks in those communities simply as bitter or clinging.

By repeating and extending the rightwing lie about Obama's statement, Don Surber actually exposes himself as the elitist. Which isn't really surprising, considering that he's backing a candidate who can't even keep count on the number of homes he owns.

Posted By: Vito (9:54am 10-13-2008)
Report Abuse


Why get uptight about this movie ?. All televison shows such as Jay Leno and David Letterman bash West Virginia every chance they get ! Don't read about Suber bashing these guys !

This is West Virginias DELIVERANCE movie, not all fact and not all fiction. Its a MOVIE !!!!

Posted By: Chilihead (12:19am 10-12-2008)
Report Abuse


Im shocked that someone isnt doing anything to point out this falsehood in the movie. I for one thought it was supposed to be factual even if it does have that racist Jim Brown promoting it.

Posted By: All to Well... (9:57am 10-12-2008)
Report Abuse


Is anyone honestly surprised by the "hillbilly" stereotype?
I'm thanking God that the outside world doesn't know the half of what goes on here, they'd really slaughter us.

It's easy to follow the top stories with home delivery of The Charleston Gazette.

Click here to order home delivery.

Advertiser
Advertiser