Rev. Matthew J. Watts: Prisons warehouse surplus labor
CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- n a recent commentary in the Sunday Gazette-Mail, Faye Taxman and Danielle S. Rudes, professors at George Mason University and Directors of the Center for Advancing Correctional Excellence, wrote the following:
"For more than 30 years the mechanism for crime fighting in the United States has focused on building and expanding the capacity of our prisons -- a phenomenon visible at federal, state and local government levels (with more cells and larger budgets)."
This view held by Professors Taxman and Rudes is shared by many experts in their field. However, it is only a partial explanation for the large increase in America's prison population over the last 30 years.
The explosive growth of America's Prison Industrial Complex is primarily attributable to America using prisons as a means of managing and controlling the surplus labor of undereducated and unskilled offenders, many who have a substance abuse or mental health issue. The growth of America's Prison Industrial Complex has also provided much needed employment opportunities for individuals who would have otherwise been unemployed due to the decline in manufacturing jobs. This decline in manufacturing jobs has resulted from advancements in manufacturing technology and the outsourcing of manufacturing jobs overseas.
The decline in the size of the U.S. military has also contributed to the surplus of under-skilled undereducated laborers in America.
Professors Taxman and Rudes, and many others, suggest that America's judges should be considering alternatives to incarceration for non-violent offenders. Many prison reform advocates agree with this position. The challenge to the implementation of this position is the complex competing economic conflict of interest created by the Prison Industrial Complex.
West Virginia's growing prison population is an example of this conflict of interest.
CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- n a recent commentary in the Sunday Gazette-Mail, Faye Taxman and Danielle S. Rudes, professors at George Mason University and Directors of the Center for Advancing Correctional Excellence, wrote the following:
"For more than 30 years the mechanism for crime fighting in the United States has focused on building and expanding the capacity of our prisons -- a phenomenon visible at federal, state and local government levels (with more cells and larger budgets)."
This view held by Professors Taxman and Rudes is shared by many experts in their field. However, it is only a partial explanation for the large increase in America's prison population over the last 30 years.
The explosive growth of America's Prison Industrial Complex is primarily attributable to America using prisons as a means of managing and controlling the surplus labor of undereducated and unskilled offenders, many who have a substance abuse or mental health issue. The growth of America's Prison Industrial Complex has also provided much needed employment opportunities for individuals who would have otherwise been unemployed due to the decline in manufacturing jobs. This decline in manufacturing jobs has resulted from advancements in manufacturing technology and the outsourcing of manufacturing jobs overseas.
The decline in the size of the U.S. military has also contributed to the surplus of under-skilled undereducated laborers in America.
Professors Taxman and Rudes, and many others, suggest that America's judges should be considering alternatives to incarceration for non-violent offenders. Many prison reform advocates agree with this position. The challenge to the implementation of this position is the complex competing economic conflict of interest created by the Prison Industrial Complex.
West Virginia's growing prison population is an example of this conflict of interest.
The West Virginia Division of Corrections has nearly 7,000 inmates. It has about 2,000 employees. If West Virginia were to reduce its prison population by one-half, then you would expect a corresponding reduction in the prison employee population. This would result in 4,000 to 5,000 individuals (inmates and prison workers) joining the ranks of the unemployed. This would result in a negative economic impact on the communities where the prisons are located. In short, West Virginia and the American Prison Industrial Complex, much like the Military Industrial Complex, have become major components of the workforce and economic underpinning of the American economy.
The American Prison Industrial Complex, like its predecessor slavery, has become inextricably woven into the social, cultural, political and economic fabric of the American experience.
However, prisons, unlike slavery, are necessary to protect the public safety because there are violent and chronic offenders whose behavior leaves us no choice but to incarcerate them. The necessity of prisons as a form of punishment for some offenders provides the opportunity for lawmakers and judges to exploit our fears to be kept safe. They lead us to believe that prisons and incarcerations are the only appropriate options for both violent and non-violent offenders, most of whom are poor.
When this philosophy prevails and there is a surplus of undereducated, under-skilled, poor people coming into the criminal justice system, then legislators will over legislate incarceration for offenders, prosecutors will over prosecute and judges will over incarcerate. When the labor of the poor non-violent offenders is devalued and no longer needed to drive the economy, and when their incarceration creates employment opportunity and economic benefit for others, then it becomes easy to justify the mass incarceration of poor non-violent offenders.
Watts is senior pastor at Grace Bible Church in Charleston.
Get Connected