Audra Clark led St. Marys to a 25-2 record on the season and returned to the first team after a year which she finished with 18 points and 10 rebounds per game.
Parkersburg Catholic's Leah Hughes averaged 17 points, 6.8 rebounds and 3.5 steals per game to earn repeat honors as well.
Wheeling Central's Emily Bucon averaged 15.3 points per game while shaking off a leg injury to led the Maroon Knights to the state semifinals.
In addition to the returnees, Valley Fayette's Alexis Payne, Notre Dame's Molly Angotti and Fayetteville's Jessica Brown round out the first team. All three were second-team selections a year ago.
For the second-straight year, Wheeling Central's Colleen McCormick captained the second team honorees.
Joining McCormick as a second-team returnee is Trinity's Jackie Halapy.
St. Joe's Asia Petitte was named a second-team selection, along with Buffalo's Chelsey Parkins and Williamstown's McKenzie Smith. All three were third-team selections in 2012.
Rounding out the second team was St. Marys' Kendra Walker, Clay-Battelle's MaKayla Wilkins and Magnolia's Mallory Chapman.
Tyler Consolidated junior Sophie Kinnard was named the captain of the third team.
Third-team returnees from 2012 include Huntington St. Joseph junior Rachel Lee and Meadow Bridge senior Chandra Harrah.
Also on the third team were St. Joe freshman Mychelle Johnson, Gilmer County junior Julie Bishop and a trio of seniors - Man's Summer Sword, Tucker County's Amber Evans and Tygarts Valley's Shanda Howell.