That's because getting two wins in the previous four games - in order to get to five and on the verge of bowl eligibility - is anything but a sure thing. And that's what makes Saturday's loss against Texas Tech so critical. The Mountaineers had a chance to win. As Holgorsen said, perhaps they should have won.
But they didn't, which means a golden opportunity slipped away.
"In the fourth quarter, when we were up [27-16], we didn't have the will to want to knock them out,'' Holgorsen said. "They had the will to want to win more than we did. And that starts with me.''
Indeed, in addition to all the other things West Virginia needs to improve upon in order to have a chance to win more than it loses over the final five games and become bowl eligible, mentality appears to be in the mix.
On Saturday, the offense began to look respectable, really for the first time this season. Even in what is West Virginia's signature win to date - a 30-21 victory over Oklahoma State - the offense seemed to succeed almost accidentally, not by design. Clint Trickett was making his first start and all but winged it and made a handful of big plays. It was the defense that scored one touchdown and set up two field goals with turnovers.
The only other times the offense scored well this season came against horrendous Georgia State and after Baylor had lost interest. But against Tech, things were actually crisp.
Or they were right up until the time the Mountaineers stopped playing with that 27-16 lead.
Perhaps "stopped playing'' isn't right, though. Holgorsen insists that it's not a matter of trying, but instead an issue of sucking it up when things get tough.
"It's not the effort. The effort was there,'' Holgorsen said. "The will to win wasn't there.''
And that's something that will have to change if West Virginia is to have a chance at reaching the only goal that remains.
Reach Dave Hickman at 304-348-1734 or dphickm...@aol.com or follow him at twitter.com/dphickman1.