I thought so, as one of them was seen a bit out of position on at least two of the four touchdowns. Remember, they were in their sixth practice in the Marshall program, playing on the first unit all along.
Give them a pass for now. They are physically impressive, showing as much Friday in the man-vs.-man hitting drill. Each clobbered his offensive foe.
Not much yet, except Jermaine Holmes is becoming a stud.
And he is becoming the unit's leader, as the middle linebacker position demands. Says Rippon: "I felt he had better control with the defense. In his way, as quiet as he is, the kids got lined up. I'll have to watch the field, but I don't believe there was a major malfunction in getting them lined up."
Playing beside Holmes and Devin Arrington on the top unit, Raheem Waiters didn't jump out at me Saturday. On the second unit, Cortez Carter shined in the middle and former safety Evan McKelvey had his first big day on the second level. Billy Mitchell was nearly invisible.
Haig has been consistent from 20-40 yards through spring and the past week, but missed a 33-yarder Saturday and had a longer try blocked. Martin hit all from four of his tries from 33 to 42 yards.
You'd like to see somebody hit a 50-yarder, which hasn't happened much in the past week. This battle continues.
At this point, I can't envision Tyler Williams not winning the punting job over Austin Dumas. He can get off a booming punt, 55 yards or more in front of the snap. But that doesn't happen every time, or close to it.
Williams knows what he needs to do: "I had some good ones, but I need more consistency. That's what I'm working on now."
But he hasn't been close to consistent, and this is where you should be frightened: He has yet to work much with the fastest operation times needed to get kicks off against an all-out rush.
Herd fans may find punting difficult to watch.
Reach Doug Smock at 304-348-5130, dougsm...@wvgazette.com or follow him at twitter.com/dougsmock.