July 1, 2009
Big deal my foot
Also, Marcum's message and ex-QBs on video
Advertiser

MORGANTOWN - Odds and ends and a few things I think I think:

  • Let's be honest about this Eugene Smith broken foot thing. If it's a big deal then West Virginia's football team is in a whole mess of trouble.
  • But it's not a big deal.

    Oh sure, you'd like to have a guy who stands to compete for your backup quarterback job to be able to do more than, well, stand in the two months leading up to the season. But we are, after all, talking about a backup quarterback. If he's anything else this season then it means Jarrett Brown is either hurt or struggling, in which case that whole-mess-of-trouble thing rears its ugly head.

    But what's the worst-case scenario (save for Smith being hobbled more than the predicted 6-to-8 weeks)? Well, it's that for the next eight weeks the true freshman is limited to putting more time into studying the playbook and throwing to - and developing a relationship with - WVU's receivers. Yes, he misses some of his conditioning work (no running or jumping, but upper-body work is OK) and is perhaps limited in what he can do during August camp, but how good does a backup quarterback's conditioning have to be?

    "Quarterback is the toughest position for a freshman to play mentally,'' WVU offensive coordinator Jeff Mullen said. "Offensive line is the toughest physically.''

    So if Smith was a left tackle being counted on to play, this would be bad news. But again, being limited physically just means he now has more time to spend on the mental part.

    Also remember that Smith hasn't even won the backup job. He hasn't even started competing for it yet. So the idea that his broken foot is some kind of a big blow is pretty silly.

  • I couldn't help but read or hear just about everywhere in the past few days about outgoing Marshall athletic director Bob Marcum's belief that his school should stand firm on a home-and-home football contract with West Virginia. And in doing so he said it was being done "in just about every state in the United States,'' citing Virginia-Virginia Tech, Iowa-Iowa State, Kentucky-Louisville and even the now-defunct Pitt-Penn State series.
  • Now, once again, I couldn't care less, although I doubt West Virginia is going to sign anything that balanced short of political intervention. And really, what's wrong with another seven-year deal exactly like the last one? Remember, had Marshall been able to win two of the first three games and earn home field for the fourth (which, by the way, is this year's game in Morgantown), that seven-year series would have been a 4-for-3, which amounts to three home-and-homes and one extra game in Morgantown. It turned out to be a 5-for-2 (look at it as a pair of 2-for-1s and an extra game at WVU), which sucks if you're Marshall, but that's no one's fault but the Herd's for losing.

    Report a violation or offensive comment.
    [X] Close
    to report abuse.
    Posted By: Bobby (1:59pm 07-04-2009)
    Report Abuse


    The only person that really wants this game is Manchin.

    There is NO LEGITAMATE REASON for WVU to play marshal. It is stupid.

    Posted By: VMIalumWVUfan (7:58am 07-03-2009)
    Report Abuse


    I say sign the deal.
    Granted, NO ONE outside the state of WV gives a rat's patoot about a WVU/Marshall game. Shoot most Marshall fans don't want the game because they know the outcome will not be favorable for Marshall.
    Granted playing Marshall does NOTHING for WVU, nor their SOS.
    Granted, playing in the high school stadium known as Marshall's stadium is pointless, I still say sign the deal.
    The BEast will soon add a ninth member and scheduling games won't be as difficult, but WVU still needs an OOC opponent.
    I'd much rather play Marshall then Liberty or Norfolk St for crying out loud.
    Besides. the main reason WVU should sign the deal, let's see how long it is before Marshall BACKS OUT of this contract as they have done before.
    And after losing to WVU for consecutive years in a row, it won't be long before they want to back out of the contract.

    Posted By: happyeer (10:04am 07-02-2009)
    Report Abuse


    it's absolutely stupid to play any games in the matchbox stadium of marshall.WVU doen'st want to play them anywhere,anytime. This is all about manchin's political ambitions, not football.
    If wvu doesn't want the game, then let's just forget it. Marshall can play a big ten school and prob ably get more tv coverage than playing wvu.
    Let's drop the whole thing, we play you in BB, and that's a pretty good game. Football?????? well, you guys are losers and will take years to turn it around....

    Advertisement - Your ad here
    Advertisement - Your ad here
    MC CORMICK JEWELERS
    A name you have know and trusted for over 60 years for honesty, quality and fair prices. The own...
    Advertisement - Your ad here